The old guy looks into his wife's eyes and takes her hand.
" I remember what was and try not to think of what might have been. I was nervous. It was a potluck supper. The group was called 'Dignity'. I was reserved. I was scared. I was a little doe in the headlights. People greeted me. The ladies quite affably, but the guys with a quick head to toe sweep of their eyes. I couldn't talk to these people. I thought that they might try to get me to do things I didn't want to do just yet. How do I go about being gay? The conversations were odd. They were studded with artificialities and half truths. 'This is not coming out', I thought; 'It's just a different closet.' Then I hear this goofy voice with a Jimmy Stewart stutter. It draws me in. It is male, affable, friendly and joyous. There he is! I can hear his thoughts. 'Hello, I'm Max.' 'John' he says, dipping his eyes to the floor. Yet a smile lingered on his lips. Not one of laughter, but of pleasure. I had never seen such a beautiful face on a guy decades my senior. Such a kind face. Such caring eyes. Such plainness. Such authenticity. Such emotional control, yet, goofy in tone and awkward in gait. He was tall, thin, bearded and a sumptuous mound of neatly coiffed hair crowned this oddity. Was he an Andrew Jackson style backwoods squirrel hunter? I said 'Have you tried the chocolate cake. It's great.' 'I made it,' he replied There were smiles all around. I thought 'Not exactly a backwoodsman; this one.' We talked the whole evening about nothing. Then it was 'Goodbye' and 'Till next time'.
One night I was drinking at the local gay establishment. I was leaning backward with my elbows on the bar, watching the boys dance. I could reach for my beer bottle without looking because I knew it was right there on my left. The hours passed. Then I reached leftward for my beer and felt a hand on my bottle. It's him! 'You're drinking my beer.' 'No you're drinking my beer.' We mock argue and laugh a lots as, together, we watch the boys dance.
I woke up. A cool wind was caressing my nude body. The breeze was stirring the curtains. Muffled voices filtered up from the street below. An arm was draped over my shoulder. I felt a pleasant warmth on my back. I was being spooned from neck to foot. I turned and saw the face of my lover. He didn't snore. There was just sweet pleasant breathing. I turned and kissed him awake. We made love. Years passed and he told me many things.
'I know that priest', he said, 'we went to seminary together.'
'I quit seminary because I couldn't live a lie.'
'Yes, I graduated from Harvard.'
'It's not that much, the company has lots of VPs.'
'I'm quite wealthy.'
'He was younger. We travelled a lot. He stole from me. He broke my heart.'
And after 10 years of friendship I suggested that we stop seeing other guys and move in together. He said 'I can not trust.' I needed more and I left. Goodbye John. I found a new love, you love. I found marriage, family, success, comfort and joy in you. But I still have sweet memories of him. I remember what was and do not consider what might have been."
The old lady nods her head knowingly.